Tuesday, February 16, 2016

Economic growth -- vastly slower than we thought (maybe)

You'd think that by now we'd have a pretty good empirical understanding of how economies grow, i.e. what the normal pattern of growth is through time. We've been studying economies for a couple of centuries, and have had reasonably good numbers of the (crude) measure of GDP for half a century. In economics -- and among the financial media generally -- it's almost beyond question that the normal pattern of economic growth is exponential growth. Indeed, almost no one ever supposes it might be different; we only debate how fast or slow recent exponential growth has been.

But we might be wrong, especially for mature economies. That's  the conclusion of some recent research by a team of European economists and statisticians who looked at the data on 18 mature economies from 1960 onwards. They find that the best fit to the data isn't exponential at all, but linear, suggesting that if growth was ever exponential (in young economies), it isn't  like that any more.

I wrote a piece in Bloomberg about this a couple weeks ago. I wasn't aware of this line of work, but apparently a handful of (mostly) German economists have been pointing to this evidence for nearly twenty years.

It would hardly be surprising, of course, if human economies -- like individual people themselves, cells, bacterial colonies, trees and anything else alive -- turn out to have natural stages of growth, with fast growth eventually slowing toward something more gradual and, eventually, stopping altogether (which wouldn't imply the end of change, just some kind of balance). Current ideas in economics might need considerable re-thinking, of course.

But that wouldn't  surprise me either.


  1. Mark,

    Maybe I can interest you in my paper that shows how this might be a general trend:


    The work grew out of an effort to produce metrics for prediction markets for the IARPA ACE program, but has turned out to be more interesting in its descriptions of macro models.



  2. Mark,

    There is some further supporting evidence for this line of thinking in this discussion paper, focusing on long run trends in GDP per hour worked:


    The shape of productivity growth in most advanced economies seems to have shifted from being exponential to being approximately linear round about 1970.



  3. The office manager cover letter is bets for the people who have economic lacks and supporting models. This is exponential.

  4. Quality content writing is very difficult in current prospective, but you having an excellent writing skills. Keep posting such nice article.Check Epic Research for best mcx, stock & forex tips.

  5. here are programs that will guess on the market. You can read the news tomorrow. (Except politicians, they can start a war, and that it could end the war). If anyone has good programs earn guaranteed money that can be used for them. If someone tries to sell you some good software that is guaranteed to win on the foreign exchange market (they are false). Some software can make your work as ISIS everything.To get more data take a tour Forex Signals

  6. Thank you for sharing such great information. It was very informative and has help me in finding out more detail about IDBI News!

  7. We can't deny the power of real management that boost your business so much. If you want to have successful career and also better growth in business then you just have to serve best services. Do better things for your company.

  8. Forex commerce is that the platform, wherever the cash is earned by commerce the currency pairs. the worth of those currencies declare the loss and profit, after they square measure purchase and sell. To become an honest monger, initial trade by gap a demo account and learn the fundamental recommendations on forex, once you square measure ok to create some cash in on the $64000 trade, then attempt yourself within the forex signals

  9. Thank you for such a valuable article. I really appreciate for this great information.contract management software

  10. I enjoyed over read your blog post. Your blog have nice information,I got good ideas from this amazing blog. I am always searching like this type blog post. I hope I will see again..
    animal jam 2 |2048 game |red ball | stick war 2 |stickman games |five nights at freddy’s 2 |five nights at freddy’s 4 |plants vs zombies |

  11. So, you want to say that the developing countries with very slow economies are going to succeed in the future? And those who have already developed will fail? Such idea is not new, but it doesn’t mean that the economists do not consider these aspects and do not refer to them in their forecast.